Comments on: Voting is now open

By: Pascalphilly

Pascalphilly — Thu, 25 Oct 2007 11:18:40 +0000

I voted for
Spreadshirt TM by Japasa

In my eyes it is the best combination of a logo that that looks like a professional company while at the same time communicating what was asked for in the briefing. Good luck!

By: wangjel

wangjel — Sun, 21 Oct 2007 23:35:07 +0000

i’m not a good designer, i was not design here nothing, i have not intention to win.
here is my vote http://blog.shayowo.org/?p=49

By: P.S.

P.S. — Sun, 21 Oct 2007 20:40:47 +0000

Hehe.. yes.. Lapsus… Thanks ikou. ; )

I don’t know what have you ment by this dog of war but actually I don’t care…
As I said before, I am not here for analysing people and just not interested in that.
Anyway he was telling some things which are pretty much close to what I think…
And I wanted to point that irrelevant fact…

By: ikou

ikou — Sun, 21 Oct 2007 20:20:55 +0000

With due respect P.S i think your reference was not Omega but 2cents dog of war.

By: P.S.

P.S. — Sun, 21 Oct 2007 20:03:54 +0000

Once again I hope that you will understand my comments since the beggining as completely benevolent. Not malicious as there were many from other people… I wasn’t even malicious with my reaction on their doings… It is just not me…

I enjoy is making designs… and yes… I am passionate about all of that…
But that is good right? ; )

And I hate to see when stupid things happens… i’ve seen it enough in my country… That is why I have participated here in the first place… Thinking that it will be better here… No coruption, no arrogant pseudoexperts… no bad organisation…

By: P.S.

P.S. — Sun, 21 Oct 2007 19:52:53 +0000

Thank you Omega for spreading the truth.
The attitude that is liberated from strong predetermined convictions.

I didn’t dare to do it on my own because my english is REALY NOT SO GOOD as you can see and I am amware that I am not able to express myself verbaly! Yet I thought that it wouldn’t be needed here actually… This supposed to be about graphic design… so no need for explanations… Yet, obviously I was wrong.
Also I am 100% possitive that I would be misunderstooded. At last someone dare to stand up and speak loud and clear…

At the end that is only thing left here… I mean to use their own public democratic chit chat game and to left ”the other voices” written down for the next generations… For the sake of the truth.

I can not believe that you have express almost about 90% of what I think as well about these proposals… But really unbelievable… Same ideas we had… Even for the examples with Uniliver and kid’s stuff for Universal language and label heads… also about Molecular confusion and stupid circle… Also some other that according to my oppinion doesen’t even deserve some serious analyses… Unbelievable… such a simmilar attitudes… I guess there must be some truth in it and some might think about your (mine) words eventually… one day…

The only difference for me was that I haven’t found SpreadShirt TM as you describe it…
Actually I found it as na interesting sign… but nothing special really.. lacking with suggestivity… and obvious description…
Also Pop Your Collar beside how you describe it (and absolutely agree with you) It gives so strong allusion to a “dog food dish” …But we could be wrong…

at the and Joe and Jane probably adore cute puppies…

And with a stong promotion like Apple, Adidas, Sony, Mercedes, Nike, Danone, etc… have…
even their pets will have their own labels soon…

Forgive me to my bad joke… I don’t like to have such a comunication… but this is really about not letting the NONSENCES TO BE SPREADED!

Don’t get me wrong… I think that ALMOST ALL of the Grandfinalists are very, VERY GOOD DESIGNERS… or they will be eventually… but we are not talking about them here…
we are talking about their answers to “SPREAD SHIRT - YOUR OWN LABEL” requests…

And they are just not so good…

By: ikou

ikou — Sat, 20 Oct 2007 12:37:56 +0000

wow
good dog good dog 2cents
A female sunflower spermatozoon generic bubble was a better definition i think.

No regrets of course, and definitely no frustation to win nothing(!) when im reading too much pathetic comments since week7, wildcards. I hope a good prize for a fairplay competitor, it’s an urgency:)

By: Laurent

Laurent — Sat, 20 Oct 2007 10:23:54 +0000

2cents (about “The signal”) : “It’s a generic image of a logo”.
Yes ! It’s a generic shape for a logo, BUT its use is unique. It’s not a classical 2D logo but reather a cloth - or a skin - who adapt to the 3D volume. In fact, it’s never the same, but always recognizable.

2cents : “he first rule of a great logo is that, IT SHOULD BE DESCRIBABLE in relations to the core of the business.”
Are you sure ? Apple, Adidas, Sony, Mercedes, Nike, Danone, etc… use your “first rule” ???

By: adam

adam — Sat, 20 Oct 2007 09:26:34 +0000

@omega: Yep you guys are, we never realized your were a design team. But I’ll add all your entries to the collaboration category :)

By: Jebs

Jebs — Sat, 20 Oct 2007 09:15:42 +0000

have voted :-)

for me 2 logos emerged really in this grand final:

1-Think Spreadshirt
2-The SIgnal

for me those ones will be strong logos for SS.

but to be honest, none of those are as strong as the last year logo…i loved the fingerprint, i still love it now, anyway, it’s not the time to begin polemics, see you ;-)